Coaxial vs Component Speakers – Which One to Choose?

One of the hottest debates these days is about which speakers to choose for your car audio. To decide which speakers should you go for, you need to have a complete knowledge of speaker types and what difference do they make in sound quality.

There are a lot of different factors that you need to take a look on to know which speakers would work perfectly for your car before you make a purchase. In this very article, we will be comparing two different car speakers which are: Coaxial and Component Speakers.

After reading this article, you would surely be able to make a decision for the ones best suitable for you.

Coaxial vs Component Speakers

Coaxial Speakers are a two-way speaker system. It consists of three main components: the tweeter, the woofer, and a crossover. All these components are assembled together as one single piece. They are the best choice if you want to replace the old, poor quality speakers within the same hole and space. And that too, without any interior modification.

Moreover, they are not very costly as compared to the new, advanced speakers. They also offer an easy installation and are quite popular for the amazing sound quality they provide.

Component Speakers have their components divided into pieces. They have a separately mounted woofer, tweeter, and crossover. You can get them fixed in separate places in order to get things one hundred percent optimal.

They are much costly as they provide next-level sound quality and performance. Moreover, their installation is not that easy. It requires time and proper techniques to get them perfectly installed. But, at the end of the day, you would prefer an outclass sound quality speaker with excellent performance even if you have to invest your time and money once into it.

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: The Differences

Installation:

Coaxial Speakers are fitted as one assembled speaker system. Their different components collectively build up a single speaker.

Also, the Coaxial speakers are easy to install and require less time for their installation.

On the other hand, Component Speakers have separate components and they cannot be assembled into one single piece. So, their components have to be installed individually. This is not the case in each and every Component speaker but in most of them.

Component speakers are a bit difficult to install as compared to Coaxial speakers. Also, the component speakers require more time and effort to get installed.

Quality of the Components:

As the Coaxial Speakers easily fit into small space and are also less costly, so they have some compromises as well, in order to make them affordable for most of the people. As a compromise, they may use the lower-cost material for the tweeter (that is -6db/octave) or a basic, common crossover.

While in Component Speakers, better quality crossovers (-12db/octave minimum) and good quality material for tweeters is used.

Power Ratings:

The Coaxial Speakers offer lower power ratings as they are less costly. The speaker power ratings of coaxial speakers are within the range of 35W to 65W RMS.

While on the other hand, Component speakers have higher power ratings. Their power ratings are under the range of 65W to 100W or even higher than this.

Sound Quality:

Coaxial Speakers, according to their price range and feasible installation, provide a very good sound quality. Although most of them provide an average sound, but still, far better than the Single-cone speakers.

While the Component Speakers provide high sound quality with greater clarity and sound effects. This is also because of their design and the separate components which are installed individually.

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: The Advantages

Coaxial Speakers:

  1. The best thing about Coaxial Speakers is that they are easy to find and get fixed. Also, they are very popular so you would probably find them in every gadget-related store or market.
  2. You can easily get the old Single cone speakers replaced with the Coaxial speakers in less time. Or, you may even upgrade your sound system by installing the new coaxial speakers as a replacement for the older factory installed.
  3. In case you face the poor frequency response because of the old speakers, coaxial speakers can fix that too.
  4. They offer a huge range of performance options. You may choose between different levels of tweeter quality, or the material being used, range of power ratings or even the crossover design.
  5. Coaxial speakers have different price ranges as well so you may choose one which is affordable for you. The best quality coaxial speakers would cost you a maximum of 50$ to 65$.

Component Speakers:

  1. Component Speakers have an amazing quality of the crossover component and the tweeters. They use a minimum of -12db/octave crossover slopes.
  2. The tweeters in the component speakers are made of aluminum, silk or ceramic mostly. They have a quite rigid design and offer great performance.
  3. The terminals of speaker connectors and the accessories for installation are also of great quality. So, they won’t expire in near future and you won’t need to get them replaced too soon.
  4. The overall accuracy of sound and the frequency of sound is excellent as well. They provide a louder sound but sweet to the ears.
  5. The component speakers offer a higher power rating which is between 65W to 1000 RMS, most commonly 75W RMS.

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: Pros and Cons

Coaxial Speakers

Pros
  • Easy to install
  • User friendly
  • Assembled components serve as a single system
  • Easy to find
  • Can be replaced easily
  • Offer a range of performance options
  • Do not require interior modification while being replaced with old speakers
  • Offer good quality sound
  • Less expensive
Cons
  • Many of the coaxial speakers are just average
  • Good sound quality, but not as amazing as that of the component speakers

 

Component Speakers

Pros
  • Amazing sound quality
  • Components are installed individually, hence providing greater sound frequency
  • Best quality crossover and tweeter
  • Enhanced design
  • Offer higher power range
  • Provides a greater range of performance options
  • User friendly
  • Provide louder yet un-irritable sound
Cons
  • A bit difficult installation
  • Require more time and effort to be installed
  • Expensive

Coaxial vs Component Speakers: Which one to choose

The choices may differ, but most commonly, the Component speakers are considered to be the superior ones to the Coaxial speakers. But still, you may choose the ones which are best suitable for your requirements and which are affordable for you. Here are a few things, according to which you would be able to decide for yourself.

Go for the Coaxial speakers:

  1. If you do not want to spend a lot of extra money and you do not prioritize very high sound effects or a high frequency beat.
  2. If you’re okay with a “not so high-end” sound quality.
  3. If you want an easy installation and you want an easy and less time-consuming way to replace your old speakers if you ever need to do that.
  4. If you want a standard sound volume and you do not intend to get your speakers enhanced or amplified.
  5. And if you do not want running extra wire for the component speakers.

Go for the Component Speakers:

  1. If you’re a fan of high-quality sound and greater beat frequency.
  2. If you would want to amplify or enhance your speakers to achieve an even greater clarity and pitch.
  3. If you prefer the best quality sound more than the difficult or time-consuming installation.
  4. If you want your speakers to be installed with higher-end electronics.
  5. If you can afford them and you’re okay with spending greater expenses on your car’s speakers.

Conclusion:

Component speakers are best known for their advanced design and the sound quality that they provide. Moreover, they have a wide range of performance options that they offer. On the other hand, Coaxial speakers too are no less. They are budget-friendly and provide the good quality sound as well.

We have tried our best to create an understandable comparison between the Coaxial and Component speakers so that it is easier for you to decide which one would fulfill your requirements well. So, at the end of the day, its totally up to you whether you go for the Coaxial or the Component speakers.

FAQs

What is the difference between component speakers and the coaxial speakers?
The main difference between the component speakers and the coaxial speakers is that the coaxial speakers combine the tweeter and woofer and build up one single speaker. Whereas the component speakers have separate tweeter and woofer and a crossover makes their job better.
Are the component speakers worth it?
Component speakers offer a great sound quality and are ideal for the loud music lovers but they are difficult to install. So, its up to you to decide if they’re worth it or not.[/wps_faq[wps_faq style="classic" question="Do the full-range speakers provide good quality sound?"]The full-range speakers cannot beat the component speakers in quality and sound but they still provide an amazing sound quality which gives you a good listening experience.
What is the best thing about Coaxial speakers?
The best thing about Coaxial speakers is that they provide great quality sound in less expenses and an easy installation. Moreover, they occupy less space as their components are combined together to make up one single speaker.

 

Leave a Comment